For the last couple of years, Battlestar Galactica has been my Top 1 Favorite television show. And I have argued vehemently that it is the best damn show on television, period.
However, I am beginning to wonder whether it has jumped the shark.
During the first couple seasons, there was a great sense of drama and urgency as the surviving humans attempted to outrun the murderous Cylons. There was mystery about who the Cylons were and how many spies had infiltrated the human population.
But this last season, beginning with the settlement on New Caprica, has been largely disappointing. We had Fat Apollo, who in the off season while the Cylons weren’t watching managed to gain 100 or so pounds as well as command of his very own battlestar. We had the human insurgency attempting to disrupt the Cylons once they had found New Caprica and decided that occupation was preferable to extermination. The parallels with Iraq were way over the top and completely unnecessary, even going so far as to give Chief a beard so that we could sympathize with radical Islamic Jihadists. Finally, once the humans had managed to escape Cylon-occupied New Caprica, we get a romantic bullshit soap opera between Apollo and Starbuck, who have both married (but not to each other) and any time they see each other they’re giving each other longing looks of “what could have been…”
Even the opening credits are problematic. Throughout the entire run of Battlestar Galactica, the credits have claimed that the Cylons have many copies, “… and they have a plan.” Well, sure they had a plan in the beginning, but we saw how the humans foiled their plan. Now the Cylons are bickering amongst themselves and seem to have lost any sense of purpose or direction. Where is their plan now? The writers should change the opening credits to read “and they had a plan.”
Let’s hope that the writers can salvage this jewel in the next episode.